spiritory logo
en
‌
Spiritory Logo
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
‌
HomeArrow rightMagazineArrow right6 Warm Whisky Drinks for Cold Evenings and Christmas Market Season

6 Warm Whisky Drinks for Cold Evenings and Christmas Market Season

Follow Spiritory on Google News

Follow Spiritory on Google News to get our latest guides and releases delivered straight to your feed.

Six warm whisky drinks for Christmas market season, from Irish coffee to Jerry Thomas's hot punch, with a method, a flavour and a whisky style for each.
Glenfiddich 12 Years Old and Highland Park 12 Years Old Viking Honour on a frosted wooden table beside a steaming hot toddy and cinnamon, with a Christmas market glowing behind.

6 Warm Whisky Drinks for Cold Evenings and Christmas Market Season

Six warm whisky drinks suit cold evenings: Irish coffee, the hot toddy, the Blue Blazer, hot whiskey punch, mulled wine with whisky and hot buttered whisky. Their histories run from an Irish coffee story dated to 1943 back to the recipes in Jerry Thomas's 1862 guide.

Key Takeaways

  • Irish coffee uses 50 ml Irish whiskey, 120 ml hot coffee, 50 ml cream and 1 teaspoon of sugar, according to the IBA.

  • The Blue Blazer is a flaming drink from Jerry Thomas's 1862 guide. Difford's Guide calls igniting alcohol extremely dangerous, so do not attempt it at home.

  • According to Stiftung Warentest, Glühwein with extra alcohol may not be sold as Glühwein, so “Glühpunsch mit Rum” is a permitted name.

  • A smooth Irish blend suits Irish coffee and punch, a malt with gentle smoke suits mulled wine and bourbon suits a buttered drink. These are our suggestions.

  • Heating removes less alcohol than many people expect, so these drinks are as strong as they taste.

Tip: Warm the mug or glass with hot water first and pour the water out. A warmed glass keeps the drink hot for longer.

Irish Coffee Is Traditionally Traced to a Foynes Chef in 1943

Irish coffee is the best known warm whisky drink. The IBA lists it among its Contemporary Classics with 50 ml Irish whiskey, 120 ml hot coffee, 50 ml chilled cream and 1 teaspoon of sugar. The coffee, whiskey and sugar are stirred first, then the cream is poured over the back of a spoon so it floats on top.

The Foynes Flying Boat and Maritime Museum dates the drink to the winter of 1943, when chef Joe Sheridan added Irish whiskey to the coffee of passengers whose flight had turned back in bad weather. Accounts differ on the year, 1942 or 1943, and on where the flight was heading, so treat this as the traditional story rather than a documented record. A smooth Irish blend such as Jameson Irish Whiskey is a safe choice, because it will not fight the coffee. For the origin, the recipe and the choice of whiskey in full, see our Irish coffee guide.

A Hot Toddy Needs Only Whisky, Sugar and Hot Water

The toddy is the simplest of the group. Difford's Guide notes that the earliest known reference to a toddy was published in England in 1741. Its version uses 45 ml blended Scotch, fresh lemon juice, honey syrup, a little sugar syrup, three dried cloves and 60 ml boiling water, garnished with a lemon slice and a cinnamon stick. It tastes sweet, citrusy and spicy.

The Blue Blazer Is a Flaming Drink for Bartenders, Not for Home

The Blue Blazer is the most theatrical warm whisky drink. Difford's Guide credits it to Jerry Thomas, author of the first bartending book, who wrote about it in his 1862 guide. Difford's Guide places its creation at the El Dorado, a San Francisco gambling saloon during the gold rush. The story of a customer who demanded "hellfire" comes from Herbert Asbury's account of 1928, so treat it as a tale rather than a record.

The method is simple on paper and dangerous in practice. Difford's Guide uses 120 ml blended Scotch and 120 ml boiling water for two drinks. The warmed whisky is lit and poured back and forth between two mugs in a long blue arc, then sweetened with powdered sugar and finished with lemon zest. Difford's Guide itself calls igniting alcohol extremely dangerous and advises practising with water first. Please do not try this at home.

The drink underneath is simply sweetened hot whisky and water. It is strong and warming, with the lemon zest adding a bright note. You can make the same ingredients in a mug with no flame at all.

Jerry Thomas Called Hot Whiskey Punch a Capital Punch for a Cold Night

Thomas's 1862 book, How to Mix Drinks, contains 81 punch recipes. The warm one for whisky lovers is the 69th Regiment Punch, as reprinted by Whisky Magazine. It uses half a wine glass each of Irish and Scotch whiskey, one teaspoon of sugar, a piece of lemon and two wine glasses of hot water, served in an earthen mug. Thomas called it "a capital punch for a cold night".

The result is gentle, lemony and lightly sweet, with the hot water making up about two thirds of the liquid. Because it mixes Irish and Scotch, it is a good way to use two bottles side by side, for example Jameson Irish Whiskey for softness and Glenfiddich 12 Years Old, a Speyside single malt, for the Scotch half. Thomas wrote that whiskey punch takes genius and that giving proportions would be impertinent, so adjust the sugar and water to your own taste.

Glühwein mit Schuss Cannot Be Sold as Glühwein

German readers know “Glühwein mit Schuss” from every Christmas market. Regulation (EU) No 251/2014 on aromatised wine products defines Glühwein as a drink obtained only from red or white wine, flavoured mainly with cinnamon and cloves, with at least 7 percent alcohol by volume and no added water. The consumer organisation Stiftung Warentest adds that Glühwein may contain at most 14.5 percent alcohol and that extra alcohol may not be added. A stall therefore cannot sell “Glühwein mit Schuss” under that name, and Stiftung Warentest names “Glühpunsch mit Rum” as a possible alternative. Made at home, the labelling rule does not apply, and whisky is simply another option.

The method is general. Warm dry red wine gently with cinnamon, cloves and a strip of orange peel, sweeten to taste and add the whisky at the end, off the heat. We suggest a malt with gentle smoke and honey, such as Highland Park 12 Years Old Viking Honour. Difford's Guide describes the nose of Highland Park 12 as heather honey with faint wisps of smoke, and the palate as lightly honeyed with a hint of smoke and cloves. If you want to know more about the smoke, read what peated means.

Hot Buttered Whisky Borrows Its Method From Hot Buttered Rum

Hot buttered rum is a classic winter drink, and Difford's Guide gives a clear template: a warmed toddy glass, 2 barspoons of honey, a knob of unsalted butter, 60 ml rum, two pinches of grated nutmeg and boiling water, stirred until the honey and butter dissolve. It is garnished with a cinnamon stick and a lemon slice studded with cloves. Difford's describes the taste as slightly oily, warming and spicy.

Swapping whisky for rum is our suggestion, not an established recipe. A sweet, round whisky is the natural choice. Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon is described by its distillery as having a complex aroma of vanilla, mint and molasses and a palate of brown sugar and spice, which we think suits honey, butter and nutmeg. Use the same quantities as the template and taste before adding more sugar.

Tip: Measure the whisky. The recipes above use between 45 ml and 60 ml of spirit per glass. Because heating does not remove all the alcohol, enjoy them slowly, drink water alongside and never drive afterwards.

FAQ

Does heating whisky remove the alcohol?

Not completely. The USDA Table of Nutrient Retention Factors lists 85 percent of the alcohol remaining when a spirit is stirred into a hot liquid, and 40 percent remaining after 15 minutes of baking or simmering. A mug of warm punch or mulled wine keeps most of its alcohol, so drink slowly and with water.

What is the easiest warm whisky drink to make?

The toddy needs only whisky, honey or sugar, lemon and hot water, and Irish coffee takes just a few minutes.

Is the Blue Blazer safe to make at home?

No. Difford's Guide calls igniting alcohol extremely dangerous. Make hot whisky with sugar and lemon in a mug instead.

Can you put whisky in Glühwein?

Yes at home, though a market stall cannot sell the result as Glühwein, according to Stiftung Warentest. We suggest adding the whisky at the end, off the heat.

Which whisky style suits warm drinks?

As suggestions, a smooth Irish blend for coffee and punch, a malt with gentle smoke for mulled wine and a sweet bourbon for buttered drinks.


About the author

Christopher Deutsch

Christopher Deutsch

I drink and collect with intention, drawn to the sherried depth of Dalmore and the balance of Yamazaki.

To the author